Until the mid 1990s I hadn’t thought much myself about the question of how to navigate the maze of different religions. I’d been raised a Christian and had never talked much to those of different religions, so probably assumed, like many people, that most of the world’s religions were broadly similar. Then in 1997 I went along to a place in London, England, called “Speakers’ Corner”.
Known as the free speech capital of the world, on a Sunday afternoon at Speakers’ Corner anyone can stand on a ladder or a soapbox and talk about what they believe. They argue, they debate. And at Speakers’ Corner I found plenty of people of other religions—but especially Muslims—willing to attack what I believed and challenge my beliefs. And those early conversations with Muslims fascinated me so much I went on to do a PhD in Qur’anic Studies. That makes me an unusual Christian I guess.
Over the last almost 30 years, I’ve had hundreds of conversations with Muslims about my faith and I’ve probably spent as much time thinking about Islam as I have about Christianity. I’ve deeply appreciated Muslim friends and academic colleagues over the years.
So given all that: why am I a Christian and not a Muslim?
I want to offer you three reasons why: first, Muhammad. Second, the Qur’an. And third—and we’ll spend most our time here—Jesus.
Those first two are the pillars that Islam stands or falls on: Muhammad and the Qur’an—but those pillars stand on nothing, they support each other. The validity of the Qur’an is based on the testimony of just one man (Muhammad), yet Muhammad’s prophethood is based on the Qur’an. And so the whole thing is viciously circular. But let’s say a bit more.
+
Thanks for visiting my Substack! My writing is free to read; no paid subscription needed. But for some pieces, I simply ask you to subscribe for free to read the whole article—you can do that by clicking below.
+



